I want to read this book all over again and mark down every brilliant line in it and force all my friends to read it and why, you ask? Because it was BRILLIANT!!
Bad Words follows two leads, Parker Navarro, a novelist whose second book will be out soon, and Selina Chan, a book critic for a magazine. Their connection is simple. When Parker's first novel was released, Selina wrote a review that made it flop. Now that Parker's second book is on the horizon, Selina's magazine gives her the assignment of reviewing it and Selina takes the job. Selina writes another blistering review and Parker confronts her at a party because of it. Their confrontation ends up in the news and a feud between them reaches heights neither expected to happen. As the feud brings all kinds of attention down on both of them, Parker and Selina start to come together on their own, working through their issues with each other, their family, friends and their careers in ways that change everything they thought they knew.
The writing and the world-building here made everything so easy to step into for this book. I was right there with Parker when he realized that the critic who panned his first book had written a similar review for his second. I was right there watching Selina as she realized her review had gone live and flat out said she should not have been the one to review it. Their reactions felt natural, their conflict easy to understand, and because of the fact that I write reviews of my own for books I read, I was able to sympathize with both sides of the equation here. Robinson made everything feel easily accessible with each point-of-view, showing us both Parker and Selina's reactions to each escalating moment of their feud. There were moments where I could understand their reasoning for what they had said or done but then there were moments where I felt that they'd gone too far with something and it was this balance that helped make the writing soar for me. Robinson didn't make it easy to love these characters because they were written in a way to show their good and their bad traits. Selina and Parker felt real and because of that, their world felt real, as well.
As for the characters, Selina and Parker were absolutely amazing. I believed their every moment, their every struggle, their triumphs and their moments of conflict. I loved how Robinson made it that it was easy for each character to make a choice that could go either way for the story at any time, to question if they were right, to wonder what the ramifications of something would become. One moment, it was easy to understand why Parker made one choice but then a moment later it was just as easy to shake my head and want to hit the back of his head because NO, why did you DO that? The same went for Selina although I will say that I loved her just a tad bit more. Where Parker seemed to come across as more emotionally motivated with the things he did, I LOVED how level-headed Selina would be when confronted with different things in the story. Her reasoning was impressive and there were moments where she talked through situations in a way that made her feel like a kindred spirit to me. I could see how much each of them tried in the different aspects of their lives and when they started to finally come together, I could see how well they would work together if they could only get out of their own way. But even though I was expecting their coming together, I could also see how simple it would be for each of them to move on and away from each other and it was that delicate balance that Robinson imbued in this story that elevated it for me as a read.
As for the rest of the cast, Robinson filled this book with a lot of different personalities that helped with driving the feud to new heights and helped with keeping the leads in a safe place where they could reassess their situations. I loved Parker's roommate, Arthur, from the moment that he appeared on the page, ready to shield Parker from Selina's review online and everything that was resulting from it. I loved Selina's friends, Jacob, who she'd known since college, and his wife Cassie, who supported Selina when she needed them all while working on their own lives as parents to a growing baby girl. We see bits of family life, a little of Selina's to show the strained relationship she has with her parents but we see all of Parker's siblings and his mom, to show how much he's made himself a problem-solver and how much he's made himself into what he thinks will make others like him. I loved how Robinson showed these pieces of the leads and then made it that when they were together, they found something different and that difference slowly became more appealing the more they got to know each other. These are everyday people with their struggles and pain, realistic because of that and able to draw readers in by being people who could actually exist.
Which brings me to the plot. The idea of this book, a critic being confronted by an author they wrote about, felt like the one of the worst things I could imagine. I could understand the wanting to confront someone, to fight back and try to make them take their words back, but the fact that Parker did it and how he did it, just made my jaw drop a little. It made me feel on edge, wondering about the effects my own reviews could have and I can only hope that my own words have never had the outcome that Selina's had. The ideas of the creative sphere of writing made me wonder about who has the right to decide what anyone can write. Selina was purposely given Parker's second book to review, for the purpose of writing something similar to her previous work. It was expected that she would write something scathing with the hope that it would garner interest from anyone wanting to see the effect her words had on the book's release. The idea seemed to suggest that as a critic, Selina's words had a certain amount of power and it made me wonder, was it right to give her that kind of credit? Was she really able to make or break someone's writing career with her words or was she only drawing attention to merits and flaws that other people would benefit knowing about a book? What if she'd written a glowing review, would they have believed her words or would they have dismissed them because it wasn't what they wanted to read from her?
Were Selina's critics right to make the "points" that they did, to suggest that she was hired for reasons other than the fact that she was a respectable writer? On the other hand, were people fair to make assumptions about Parker's writing, to zero in on lines that they thought were "offensive" when they didn't know what motivated Parker to put those words on the page in the first place? By using words online to criticize Parker and Selina, couldn't it be argued that the audience was just doing the same thing, passing judgement without knowing the whole story, giving too much power to the words they read and the words they were writing in response? How could they pass judgement on something that didn't involve them and weren't the many different responses only showing their own character as opposed to revealing anything true about the two people at the heart of the feud? I loved the discussion this created in the book, the fact that it questioned the effect words have and how learning to see both sides helped Parker and Selina to find the right words for each other going forward. I loved how they both seemed so staunch in their positions before learning to bend, to see a bigger picture, to understand that there was something to benefit from with getting to know each other and the how and whys for the choice of words they would write. They were able to cut out the words of other people and only pay attention to the ones that they cared about, the words that mattered most, and that was a beautiful concept to see come to fruition in the story.
That last line of the book made me smile, the idea it provoked for me making me feel content in a way I wasn't expecting from this story. It was a beautiful book, there's no other way to say it.
Rating on my Scale: 10 Stars. Was there really any doubt I would give it 10 Stars? Well, yes, in the beginning there was but I was willing to see what everything came down to and I'm so grateful I took the chance to read this book. I'll be looking into everything that Rioghnach Robinson has written and will write for the rest of time.






