Sometimes a horror story doesn't hit you all at once. It takes its time, leaving bits of itself behind in the recesses of your mind, making you question the shadows that move in the dark or even walk a little faster past the dark corners in your room. It leaves a sense of dread and then it keeps building on that, and you just let it wash over you because it's so much fun to be creeped out. That's what happened with The House Built on Alligator Bones by Sophia Huneycutt. I've already received my hardcover in the mail and have it safe on my shelf. I was impressed with the way this story built its legend and the way it resolved its conflict and I am officially looking forward to whatever Huneycutt writes and publishes next.
The story is very easy to slip into from the start. Dartrine Beaumont has just lost her mother and believes there is nothing left for her, in terms of family, in her world. Then she finds a letter from a long lost grandmother and suddenly Dart has family again, family that her mother purposely kept her from, and Dart decides to take a chance and make the trip to her family's alligator farm to learn more about her mother and where her family came from. Greer House felt like its own character, this looming gothic estate that was covered in portraits of the family matriarch and decorated with an alligator skin, the one that started the family's journey into farming alligators. Huneycutt had a way of leaving enough to question about Dart's past, to wonder at the way her mother treated her by cutting Dart of from everything, and to warily eye the way things were run at the Greer House. Dart starts to expand in ways that she wasn't able to before and it happened so naturally over the course of the writing, leaving readers rooting for her as she starts to uncover the truth about her family.
In terms of characters, I did come to love Dart over the course of the story. I knew there was something that she was hiding but when it was finally revealed, I felt it was justified. I'm surprised it took her so long to fight back. I thought with all things considered that Dart had managed to come out better than her family and that made all the difference to me in the end. Gazzie was exactly what I expected her to be, this long lost grandmother with her secrets and beliefs, but the reveals made the twists a little more worthwhile and I loved the way things played out in the end for her. Aunt Virginia, Gazzie's sister, was a sweetheart but I didn't care for her as much as I thought I would considering that she was left out of the book a bit. Harrison was the heir to the farm, an outsider who had managed to make a home for himself working for Gazzie, who also tried to help Dart in her search for answers. And the answers they found made sense with the house itself, the way it seemed to move and breathe in ways that reminded me of other mansions with skeletons in their closets.
The reveals worked, the way the story moved, leaving a trail of clues to follow that made me want to understand exactly what was the driving force of this book. A lot of this brought to mind the question of nature versus nurture and I left this book still firmly on the nurture side of the argument. Characters made their choices, a lot of them questionable and for the worse, and I wanted Dart to find her place that was solely hers. A lot of this book depends on the reveals it gives and thankfully the reveals in this were the kind that were surprising enough and yet believable at the same time that they just worked. Was it a little bonkers in some ways? Oh absolutely, but I was all for the creepiness and the way it was coming to light in this book. And don't get me started on the alligator bones themselves. That reveal deserves to be experienced for yourself by reading the book.
In the end, this was a very respectable addition to Gothic literature and to horror stories in general. I look at this book and think of the ending and just smile, because I was content with where things were left for the characters. I'll be keeping an eye out for what comes next from Sophia Huneycutt.
Rating on my Scale: 10 Stars. I would go on and on about what was hiding in this house and how it came to be there but readers just need to give this book a read for themselves. It's a very good story and a lot of fun.
My thanks to NetGalley, Dutton and Sophia Huneycutt for the eARC of this book in exchange for a honest review. All opinions are my own.






